Tags: Kia Gustakhi Rasool Ka Haq Sirf Musalmanoo Ka hai?, Naumann Ahmed Ansaari
v. true i wish we muslim can understand it
sorry to differ you.
ye fard e wahid ka amal hai? to kea apny few days pehly jo Barak obama ny speech ki wo suni? kiun us fard e wahid k amal ko support kia? kiun kaha k ye freedom of expression hai? jb aik gove kisi individual k action ko endorse kr rahi hai to wo fard e wahid ka amal kahan raha?
2nd passage mein apny Hadhrat Muhammad PBUH sy starat kia aur pura paragragh ajeeb andaz mein likha k samjh nahi ati k khatam kahan hota hai.
apny likha k “””””””Muhammd bin Abullah ki zaat ki ehmiat dunia ki kisi b zaat ki ehmiat jitni hai???? i dont know ye apny sawal kia hai ya comment kia hai? matlab kea kehna chahty hain ap? k apki zaat ki ehmiat waqai dunia ki kisi zaat ki ehmiat jaisi hai ya us sy ziada hai?
next ap ikhitlaaf ki baat krty hain . han ikhtilaaf hota hai zaroor hota hai lakin jitny logon ky naam apny mention kiye un sy ikhtilaaf aur Ap Salaaho alehi waalehi wasalim sy ikhtilaaf mein frq hai afsoos apny donon ko aik hi line mein khada kr dia aur phir explain b nai kia k kea in names sy ikhtilaaf aur Ap ki zaat sy ikhtilaaf ki surat mein kea hukam hai?. aur samjhana ye chaha k jahan baqi sbsy ikhtilaf ho sakta hai ap sy b ho sakta hai???????
isi doran ap baat krty krty ahle sunnah ki trf aa jaty hain k unhon ny Nabi ki qabr ko khuda jitna darja de dia aur phir mazaraat ki baat krty hain k unko sajda gah bana lia gea waghaira waghiara. halan k apny aik b kitaab nahi parhi hogi ahle sunnah k aqaid pr k unki books mein awlia k mazaarat k bary mein kea openion hai ya unka kea point of view hai lakin kiun k bs chal chalai ka mela hai so idhar udhar sy suni aur forward kr di.
phir apny likha k Nabi pak ny frmaya k meri baat k aagy kisi ki baat ko ehmiat na dena aur logon ny apny apny imammon aur muftiunk naamon ki nisbaat laga li. wah kea andaaz hai misal de rahy hain k Ap ny frmaya k meri baat k aagy kisi ki baat ko ehmiat na dena aur ap aagy misal de rahy hain naamon ki nisbat lagany ki? kea ye realevent example hai?
phir apny Fiqha ki misaal talaq k hawaly sy di k kis trha fiqha daaniun ny 3 tallaq ko 3 keh kr logon k gharon ko ujada hai. aur afsoos apny halaly ka lafz use kia although ap janty hain k jis trha apky maslak mein hr moulvi itni aqal nahi rakhta jitni ap rakhty ho isi trha deen k boht sy moamlaat mein ulama ki opeion different hoti hai .
aur Bidha ko hasna kaa naam shaitaan ny dia? kea ap nahi janty k bidha ki kitni qismen hain? sirf aik ya aik sy ziada?
fiqha apko itni hi takleef deti hai to aur ye aisi hi insaani shariat saazi hai aur islaam mein iska koi amal dhakal nahi to phir khilafat usmaania jo pichaly 300 saal pehly tooti hai ye fiqha hi wahan pr raaij thi aur dunia k tamaam countries mein isi fiqa k mutabiq faisly hoty thy. aur main agr yahan detail dena shoro kron to jaisy ap kehty hain k page k page full ho jaen main b kr sakta hon.
han koi Apki zaat ki ehmiat kam nahi kr sakta lakin iska matlab ye kahan nikalta hai k hr kisi ko aisi bakwaas krny ki ijaazat de di jay?
han ehtjaaj ka tareeqa ghalt hai lakin ye b aik reaction hai k agr riasat theek treeqy sy action le to log aisa nahi kren gy.
every word rings true
WELL WRITTEN & A COMPLETE TRUTH !
WE OURSELVES DOING “GUSTAKHI ” NOT ONLY TO OUR PROPHET SAW BUT TO OUR ALLAH BY NOT OBEYING HIS ORDERS!
IN MY OWN OPINION ITS NOTHING NEW BY THE WAY ! WE MUSLIMS HAD DONE THE WORST EVER “GUSTAKHI E RASOOL SAW” WHEN YAZEED ‘S LASHKER OF HUNDRED THOUSAND “MUSLIMS” SHAHEED OUR BELOVED IMAM E AALE MUQAM ! WAS NOT THAT WORST EVER BLASPHEMY FROM MUSLIMS TO OUR BELOVED PROPHET SAW ???
“WE MUSLIM” HAD done???
NO WE MUSLIM did not do it.
if you want yourself to be part of yazeed crime to do it as individual do not include US (MUSLIMS)
ambiguity in your question !!!
Can you please state something concrete ??
OK ! IF YOU HAVE ANY DOUBT THAT THE YAZEED’S LASHKER WAS COMPRISED OF MUSLIMS ..THEN PLZ. GIVE ME ATLEAST 20 NAMES OF SOLDIERS IN YAZEED’S LASHKER WHO WERE NON MUSLIMS, JEWS , CHRISTIANS ETC…
tehreer to achi hai magar es main jhot be elmi b shamil hai maslan hozor ko aam dunyavi logo jaesa samajna kam elmi hi nahi balke aap ki jorrat hai wagarna hamara aqeeda BAD AZ KHUDA TO HI BOZARG QISSA MUKTASIR hai ALLAH PAK NE AAP K HAR AMAL KO WAHHI(ALLAH K TARAF SE BEJA JANE WALA KALAM ) FARMAYA AUR AAP K ZINDAGI KO BEHTAREEN OSWA NAMOONA to maqsood ye k aap s.a.w ki zaat ko beyan krne k liye kisi aur ki mesaal dena kya ye GOSTAAKHI nahi
JANAB NE YE LEKHA K MUFTI OLMA NE AAJ K SOODI NEZAM KO ISLAMI KAHA HAI TO JANAB YE BE ELMI NAHI BALKE SARASAR JHOOT HAI MUFTI TAQI USMANI SHB KA SHARIYAT COURT KA FAISLA AAJ B MOJOOD HAI AAP WO PADH LE YA KISI DARUL EFTA KA FATWA MANGWA LE MUJE YAQQEN E KAMIL HAI AAP KO ES SOODI NEZAM K HAQ MAIN FATWA KOI NAHI DEGA AGAR MELA TO HM KO B SHARE KR DEN
EK AUR BAAT AAP AUR MAIN YA KOI B AALIM O MUFTI TALIBAL KO KAFIR QARAR NAHI DE SAKTE CHAAE HAZAR EKHTELAAF HO Q K ISLAM AQEEDE KA NAAM HAI MERI AAP KI PASAND KA NAAM NAHI HAA JIHAD K MUNKIR AUR JIHAD KO BORA KEHNE WALE K EMAAN KA AAP KISI DARUL EFTA SE MALOOM KR LE SAHABA R.A B AAAS MAIN LADHE THE JANG E JAMAL MASHOOR HAI MAGAR KISI NE KISI KO KAFIR NAHI KAHA BALKE JB SHAM KO JANG ROKTI TO EK DOSRE KI KHABAR LENE EK DOSRE K LASHKAR MAIN jaate the
aur haa kisi b ferqe k maanne waale ne apne badho ko ALLAH na darja nahi diya hai
As i have said earlier
Do not write about anything you do not know
and do not use your platform to promote your false knowledge on religion.
Mr. Reader, Do not give sweeping statement without solid arguments with references.
Wah raha bahi …. ak simple si misal don ka agr app ka baap ko koi tapar mar da app ka samna to app kia us ko samjayan gaan ka bahi asa nai hota ya phr app ghar ma gus kar kahin gan ka pala ma acha ikhlaq bana lon ????? ya phr us ka sar phar daan gaan. Agr app ka samna app ka ghr walon ki izat uchali jaya to app qalam la kar likhana start kar daan ga ikhalyat par ??????
kuch host ka nakhon lo … manta hon ka itajaj ma apnon ka nuqsan karna galat ha par is ka ya hergaz maqsad nai ka ka apni nabi ki tohaeen bardast kar laan…. agr wo fard e wahid ka masla tha to Kate ki nangi pics be fard e wahid ka masla tha to kun us par itna shor kia gaya tab kahan gai azadi e izhar ???
to kia ukhar kiya aap nay ya kisi bhi ehtajaj kurnay walay nay ?
agar aapkay baap ko eik drone say maar diya jai (Tappar tou door kee baat hai) tou main dekhon ga aap kia bigar saktay ho drones ka ?????
Janab ghairat woh nahin jo kumzoron pay jagay !!!
Agar waqai kuchh kurna chatay ho tou woh kuro jis say tumhara dushman bhi pachtai kay us nay kis say larai mool lee. Tumharay apnay mulk kee fauj aur hukoomat tou unki ghulami kur rahay hain aur chalay hain baray mian amreeka ko sudharnay ??
Well the intention might be good but this writing is a piece of confusion.
You start with the thing that Americans would be hurt by our ‘Ehtajaj’.. so far we have not made any damage whatsoever to Americans, its all we have destroyed our country, our people and our property. So why they will be hurt and not us? The way of ‘ehtajaj’ is off-course wrong, this point is true but your explanation is hell of a confusion.
You start with Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and move towards other personalities while its totally different, if someone is disrespecting Muhammad Ali Jinnah , i would feel bad but its not same as Prophet MUhammad(PBUH), the feelings are different for our beloved Prophet. Do not mix everything with Him.
You said Shaitan Islam ka Libada Orh ker Agaya…do you really bear responsibility for your sentence?? Are you trying to tell that teachings we have are from shaitan? or you mean we have become shaitan’s followers?? be careful for such sentences.
You are a strong opponent of Firka and multiple explanations of Shariat…so you mean all the work that is done after Prophet Muhammad(PBUH);s life to explain his teaching is absurd? or the version and explanation you LIKE is the best one? You can off-course differ from what others follow but you can not issue ultimate statements in view of your own thinking.
you address muslims ( offcourse only those whom you consider a muslim :P) and you further go on saying them ‘Munafikoon’ and ‘Bey deen’… Have you ever heard Prophet Muhammad(PBUH) addressing people like this? you are humiliating people, the readers of your article by such words. Either it is Arrogance or Ignorance.
My humble suggestion is, you need a lot of open mindedness and knowledge before writing on religious topics..Kindly avoid this as this does not seem your domain at least for the moment….
Dear Rubab, thanks for keen observing on my writing, and I encourage your evolving ability from news. However, I would suggest you to go over into terminology because as far as I think that misunderstandings begin with little or no knowledge about it. I have not used word ‘the U.S.’ instead I have deemed citizens of U.S. in the beginning part of my writing. For your better understanding my point there is that a greatest gulf between common American people and those who run America is found which we have to realize here.
Second part of your question; my answer is, you are miles way back to understand rifts and breaches that had been made into Islamic principal of ‘Oneness’ [single being entity and only plenipotentiary(ALLAH)] and the personality of Muhammad PBUH. If you would know a little about that, I’m sure you had not asked that.
Answer of the third paragraph is whatever you are asking to me about Islam-Satan, have you ever asked to yourself? Find it … not just from books you have been given from your elders but let yourself free and let your thinking on the meditation of truth seeking.
Also I advise that one should known and believe on what real shariya is—and not that men-made fiqs that making common man’s life worst in sub-continent. I give you a simple formula to follow genuine shariya here. Just whatever comes to you – try to understand it under the light of miraculous Qur’an and reading wonderful components of Sunnah like Bukha’ri and Muslim and when find from this process anything which is not against or contradict the education of Islam through Qur’an and Sunnah—you must stick with it with all of your mind and body.
Lastly, an atheist is called atheist just as same a Muslim is called Muslim. Sometime people are called with their faith tendencies rather their general name so there is no point of defaming others in my writing or to be displeased.
“My humble suggestion is, you need a lot of open mindedness and knowledge before writing on religious topics..Kindly avoid this as this does not seem your domain at least for the moment….”
Above are your lines which reveal me that you are something in that domain or at least you consider others simpleton, which is another dilemma of every single member of our society. You are not that different at all.
Brother Nouman.. I am surprised at the reply..you are replying me as if you are a sea of knowledge and i failed to benefit from that sea.
In every single answer, you are telling me that i am not capable enough to understand the DEPTH of KNOWLEDGE in this article. I could have ACCEPTED that if you would have answered anything ACADEMICALLY rather than telling me to get more knowledge to understand this. I expect a writer to respect those who criticize his writings.
You say I do not understand the difference between ONENESS of ALLAH and the personality of Prophet Muhammad(PBUH)….well i try to read and understand my deen as i can and I am always open to listen to more knowledge..I did not ask you this difference in my response earlier nor i made any point on that…I talked about two personalities Qaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah and Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).
Well your reply on shariah thing…I did not ask you to explain me shariah..so there is no answer as your reply is different from my point…
BROTHER i am NOT asking you about shaitan…i raised a question based on your article which you did not answer.
and lastly my point was you are calling Muslims as Munafik and Bey deen…instead of answering this you are telling me muslims are called muslims as athiest an athiest..so what to get out of it…
I am NO ONE in the domain..i am just a simple reader on saach tv…it is not my dilemma, i am NOT SAYING that i know everything. Instead unfortunately it seems your dilemma and you are not realizing it.
If you do not welcome discussions, i should stop commenting anything on your writings and you live in your world where you are the best AALIM e DEEN. Its harsh but its true as i see your reply.
Perhaps we need to understand each other’s opinion and thoughts with more precise way.
I have not jeered anything of you as argumentation is not my realm. If you have elicited points from my reply–on the basis of your fiq-oriented-knowledge that has made you offended; I apologise though.
I often like to leave clues in my writing because I know people of this country as well as Muslims of this continent are intolerable and act or make opinion blindly. You appear to me that you’re kind of person who ‘thinks’ so there is much in my writing to understand and awareness for you. All you have to do is to keep your open of your ‘eyes of the mind’.
I think an independent observer can read and tell , whats ‘fiq-oriented-knowledge’ in my response? its something very common in my view. If you have pre made animosity towards specific fiqh, its another thing.
Either i severely lack knowledge to understand these things or its the other side.
When questions are asked an author should reply because the one who is asking is not understanding something…Answer of everything can not and should not be ‘go and read yourself’.
By the way, i made fiqh related comments on your previous articles, probably thats how you extract this but there is nothing that stuff here…
good luck…in my opinion you are disrespecting towards comments and you are making personal points. So i feels its worthless discussing anything with you. you do not bear difference of opinion. again its my opinion you can differ. probably you want people of your own opinion to read your columns. may God guide you.
one part of your article is good and thought provoking for muslims, that we should be a true muslim in our behaviour, thought and deeds as our prophet Muhammad Peace be upon him taught us through his sunnah and which Allah SBT wants abt momaneen, but on the other hand your stance abt america is not right , America is sporting that fard e wahid which shows their on the whole mentality. ye fard e wahid ka amal hai? to kea apny Barak obama ki speech suni? kiun us fard e wahid k amal ko support kia, kiun kaha k ye freedom of expression hai… jb aik government kisi eak insan k action ko endorse kr rahi hai to wo fard e wahid ka amal kahan raha who tu abb poray america ki taraf say hay otherwise thegovt should take immediate action to banand to punish …
thx for endorsing my words.
Great wonderful…you have done it again. Nouman you are the master avid writer. Will you please write for my program..
Dear writer, your inspection into our society, history, and off course Islam seems deep and whatever you have written down here, is true description of us. May Allah give you more power to write well about truth, more and more. We need such writer in our country.
Nouman..I just want to say that being a TV journalist myself I don’t know you around but let me say that your potential journalistic enthusiasm peeps out from your writing. You have hit the facts brilliantly and the narration is wonderful. I beg your pardon to be personal with you but can you please your email address or contact number for a journalistic reason here at my production house?
Akhir matlab kiya hay iss bakwass ka?
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>